In this task, we were required to grade a written essay in
groups. After read through the passage, Fatin Salbiah and I had agreed on
giving the student 9 marks out of 20, which means we failed him. We had decided
on that mark because we find it difficult to understand few sentences in the
passage. In addition, we have to relate ourselves to most of the story to get
the entire picture in it. For me, I have to read several times on the essay to
get the flow of the story as he was using limited vocabulary and plenty of
grammatical errors not to mention the spelling. Moreover, most of the sentences
were translated from mandarin. However, after listening to what Miss Yoon had
commented, we were not supposed to fail the student's essay as long as we can understand
the flow of their story based on the title although there were junks of errors in it. Through this task,
I find it was actually quite challenging for teachers to do grading because there are more aspects to be concern at rather than the grammar or
vocabulary itself.
You as a teacher can decide to pass or fail the students. More importantly, justify your decision if others question you:)
ReplyDelete